Gender Identity and DEI Ballot Initiatives in Arizona
Among the decisions Arizonans must make this election season are whether to approve two ballot measures, one concerning transgenderism and another concerning “Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion” (DEI). Both require thoughtful consideration on the part of Grand Canyon State voters.
Proposition 318 addresses how both public- and private-school athletic competitions will henceforth be governed.
According to the ballot language, the proposition would:
- require “private schools, public schools, and athletic associations to designate every athletic team as male, female, or coed/mixed based on sex and to prevent males from joining female teams”;
- prohibit “schools and athletic associations from authorizing anyone to use private spaces (such as restrooms) not designated for that individual’s sex”;
- define “sex” as “an individual’s biological status as male or female as recorded at birth on an original birth certificate”; and
- authorize “athletes to sue schools and athletic associations that knowingly violate this law.”
A “no” vote would “have the effect of maintaining the current laws relating to student athletics.” Current law bars male public-school students from participating on girls’ teams but does not apply to many private schools and does not address locker rooms.
As is frequently the case when such questions come before the public, advocates and opponents of Prop 318 posture themselves as focused on how best to protect Arizona children.
The Arizona ACLU argues, for example, that the measure would “insert politicians and lawyers into our bathrooms, locker rooms, and coaches’ offices,” while the supportive organization the Center for Arizona Policy (CAP) stresses the dangers associated with forcing biological women and girls to share playing fields with men and boys.
Do No Harm asks Arizonans to consider the finding that males have a physiological athletic advantage, as institutions as disparate as the U.S. Supreme Court and the International Olympic Committee now agree.
Differences in lean mass, cardiac output, and skeletal geometry appear before puberty and widen sharply after it, a process affecting not only the respective sexes’ athletic performance on average but also female-athlete safety during competition.
Crucially, published research finds that testosterone suppression narrows but does not close the performance gap, which is why the eligibility question does not resolve itself pharmacologically when female-identifying males undergo hormone therapy.
While the performance capacity of individual male and female athletes will obviously vary, science shows that post-pubescent biological males retain significant physical advantages over biological females.
A second Arizona ballot measure, Proposition 142, would amend the state constitution to prohibit
- “compelling individuals to support preferential treatment or discrimination based on race or ethnicity as a condition of education, employment, or contract opportunities”;
- “spending public money on positions in public education responsible for promoting preferential treatment or discrimination based on race or ethnicity”;
- “implementing disciplinary practices that treat students or employees differently based on race or ethnicity”; and
- “requiring or asking an applicant, employee, student, or contractor to provide a statement in support of race-based diversity, equity, and inclusion beyond upholding the federal Equal Protection Clause or asking such a person to discuss the person’s race or ethnicity or experience with others’ race or ethnicity.”
An important part of the analysis of Prop 142 is how Arizona’s healthcare pipeline might be affected by what is, at heart, a set of anti-DEI provisions.
Should Prop 142 be approved by voters, public medical schools would be prevented from using candidates’ agreement or disagreement with DEI standards — “[their] support [for] preferential treatment or discrimination based on race” — as criteria in the hiring and admissions processes. Opponents argue that this result risks narrowing talent pipelines, limiting innovation, and reducing access to opportunity for otherwise qualified candidates.
Arizona voters should take their time to familiarize themselves with these proposals and understand the full implications before casting their ballot.

