How Will Colorado Protect Children?
Two Colorado ballot initiatives are asking voters to help determine how the state will interact with gender-dysphoric minors.
The first, Proposition 134 (previously Initiative 109), concerns the use of sex-based categories in school sports.
It asks
- whether “participation in all K-12 and collegiate school sports” should be “based on the participant’s sex” and
- whether educational institutions must henceforth “designate each school or intramural [team] as male, female, or coeducational” and enforce those designations.
The text of the proposition is worth perusing in its entirety. Debate, however, has largely concerned questions of fairness and safety, values claimed by both opponents and supporters of the measure.
Nadine Bridges, executive director of the LGBTQ+ advocacy group One Colorado, told news outlet Colorado Politics, for example, that the proposition in question is “written … vaguely” and “open[s] the door to unintended consequences that can cause serious harm to all of our kids.”
Proponent organization Protect Kids Colorado, meanwhile, states that “[b]igger, stronger biological males are invading girls’ sports in Colorado, taking away our girls’ dignity, safety, and opportunity.”
Do No Harm adds that male athletic advantage is a physiological finding, not a matter of opinion, as institutions as disparate as the U.S. Supreme Court and the International Olympic Committee now agree.
Differences in lean mass, cardiac output, and skeletal geometry appear before puberty and widen sharply after it, a process affecting not only the respective sexes’ athletic performance on average but also female-athlete safety during competition.
Crucially, published research finds that testosterone suppression narrows but does not close the performance gap, which is why the eligibility question does not resolve itself pharmacologically when female-identifying males undergo hormone therapy.
While the performance capacity of individual male and female athletes will obviously vary, science shows that post-pubescent biological males retain significant physical advantages over biological females.
The second measure, Proposition 135 (previously Initiative 110), would modify existing Colorado law “by prohibiting surgery on a minor for the purpose of altering the minor’s biological sex characteristics.” (The full text, which governs both what healthcare professionals may do and what state or federal funds may pay for, is available online.)
Here, too, both opponents and supporters of the measure lay claim to the mantel of child protection, with Families Not Politics, the One Colorado–led campaign against the measure, maintaining that the change could “interfere with medically necessary care for serious conditions that affect kids well beyond transgender youth” and Protect Kids Colorado pointing to the “irreversible” nature of such procedures.
Important for Colorado voters to keep in mind is that Proposition 135 is about minors’ access to “gender-affirming care.” The measure in question is about age, not the ability of adults to consent to medical procedures performed on their adult bodies.
Systematic reviews commissioned by national health authorities in England, Sweden, and Finland found the evidence for pediatric gender interventions to be weak or of low quality, and each of those health systems has narrowed pediatric transgender practice in response.
Moreover, loss of future fertility is a foreseeable consequence of some of these procedures, and consent doctrine treats such irreversible interventions in minors severely.
Even the terminology attending the debate can teach us something. “Treatment,” a word used often by advocates of pediatric “gender-affirming care,” implies a diagnosis, an endpoint, and a demonstrated benefit.
Both ballot measures have lasting consequences for how children can be protected from potentially harmful activities and interventions.
That is the crux of the matter and the question that Centennial State voters should answer this fall. Colorado voters should take their time to familiarize themselves with these proposals and understand the full implications before casting their ballot.

