Washingtonians Consider ‘Gender’ Initiatives
Two citizen-initiated ballot measures in the State of Washington are asking voters to consider protections for girls in school sports and the rights of parents to know and oversee how schools interact with their children where healthcare matters are concerned.
The first, Washington Initiative 638, otherwise known as the Sex Verification Requirements for Female School Sports Initiative,
would prohibit students it defines as “biologically male” from competing in certain school athletic activities intended for female students only. It would require verification of biological sex by students’ healthcare providers.
The second, Washington Initiative 001, the Parental Right to Review Education Materials, Receive Notifications, and Opt Out of Sexual-Health Education Initiative,
would repeal amendments to a statute listing certain rights of parents and guardians of public-school children and re-enact the law as it was originally enacted by Initiative to the Legislature 2081.
A closer inspection of both measures is helpful. As Ballotpedia makes clear (quoting from the Washington Secretary of State’s website), “Initiative 638 would require school districts and nonprofit organizations that regulate interscholastic activities to ‘prohibit biologically male students from competing with and against female students’ in sports [that have] separate team or individual competitions for male and female students.”
Furthermore, the initiative “would require students seeking to participate in athletic activities designated for female students to submit documentation from their healthcare provider verifying ‘the student’s biological sex [based on] … reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup, or normal endogenously produced testosterone levels’.”
Male athletic advantage is a physiological finding, not a matter of opinion, as institutions as disparate as the U.S. Supreme Court and the International Olympic Committee now agree.
In addition, differences in lean mass, cardiac output, and skeletal geometry appear before puberty and widen sharply after it, a process affecting not only the respective sexes’ athletic performance on average but also female-athlete safety during competition.
Published research finds that testosterone suppression narrows but does not close the performance gap, which is why the eligibility question does not resolve itself pharmacologically when female-identifying males undergo hormone therapy.
While the performance capacity of individual male and female athletes will obviously vary, science shows that post-pubescent biological males retain significant physical advantages over biological females.
Concerning Initiative 001, Ballotpedia advises that the measure would “re-enact the following rights, which HB 1296 repealed” in 2025:
- the right of parents “to receive prior notification about medical services being offered to their child, except in medical emergencies”;
- the right of parents “to receive prior notification about medical services or medications provided that could affect the parent’s or guardian’s health insurance costs”; and
- the right of parents “to receive prior notification when the school arranges medical treatment that requires follow-up care after school hours.”
Initiative 001 is perhaps best thought of as restoring parents’ right to be notified in a medical context. Current U.S. Supreme Court precedent considers parents to be the primary decisionmakers for their child’s healthcare, and the availability of health-related instruction or services at a school probably does not change that fact, though the Court has not specifically ruled on the question.
Do No Harm urges Washington voters to carefully consider the proposed measures and evaluate the consequences prior to voting.

