Wisconsin Voters to Consider Discrimination Amendment
This election cycle, Wisconsinites will vote on Question 3, a legislatively referred amendment to the state constitution formally known as the “Prohibit Government Discrimination or Preferential Treatment Amendment.”
The discourse surrounding the question has not been thorough, and additional analysis is warranted.
First the text. Wisconsinites will see the following on their ballots:
QUESTION 3: “Governmental entity discrimination prohibited. Shall section 27 of article I of the constitution be created to prohibit governmental entities in the state from discriminating against, or granting preferential treatment to, any individual or group on the basis of race, sex, color, ethnicity, or national origin in public employment, public education, public contracting, or public administration?”
While both the U.S. and Wisconsin constitutions already mandate legal equality, race-based programs and preferences have continued to exist at the state and local levels of government. The proposed amendment would further strengthen the prohibition on governmental discrimination for any reason.
At stake, as acknowledged by both supporters and opponents, is the ability of Badger State officials to balance disparities by enacting policies that favor certain groups.
State Senator Chris Larson explained his opposition to the amendment in a January press release on the grounds that the amendment would “preven[t] any government program in Wisconsin from … attempting to reverse [the] state’s shameful racial, ethnic, and gender disparities.”
State Senator Stephen Nass has argued for the amendment on strikingly similar grounds: “Past discrimination, however wrong, cannot be corrected with more discrimination. Old Wounds cannot be healed by inflicting new ones.”
However, what has been largely missing from the debate is analysis of how the amendment would affect Wisconsin’s healthcare pipeline, most prominently by impacting which candidates are admitted to the state’s public medical schools.
This is a serious matter. As Do No Harm chronicled last year, black applicants to the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health (UWSMPH) had nearly 10 times the odds of admission compared to Asian or white applicants with the same MCAT score and GPA, according to the institution’s 2024 admissions data.
Black students accepted to UWSMPH had an average MCAT score in the 62nd percentile, whereas whites were in the 86th percentile and Asians in the 87th.
Based on that year’s data, the acceptance rate for black applicants to UWSMPH was more than six times greater than that of Asian applicants.
Given the clear link between MCAT scores, medical-school outcomes, and performance on licensing examinations, these elevations of race and ethnicity over academic merit have legitimate public-policy consequences.
At least arguably, Wisconsin is not training the most promising future physicians who knock on its institutional doors.
Badger State voters should consider carefully the specifically medical consequences of Question 3.

