DSM, Not DEI
A series of commentaries in the May 2026 issue of the American Journal of Psychiatry plots a future “roadmap” for the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), a new version of which is currently being planned by the American Psychiatric Association’s Future DSM Strategic Committee.
For the sake of patients of all races and ethnicities, we hope these stated plans for the future DSM are seriously reconsidered.
Our reason is that at least two of the articles approach psychiatric diagnostics from a politicized angle. Indeed, it is not too much to say that the principles of “Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion” (DEI) are among the most important philosophical — we do not say scientific — pillars holding up the proposed DSM edifice.
Take, for example, “The Future of DSM: A Strategic Vision for Incorporating Socioeconomic, Cultural, and Environmental Determinants and Intersectionality,” whose lead author, Milton L. Wainberg, MD, is chair of the Future DSM Strategic Committee’s Socioeconomic, Cultural, and Environmental Determinants of Mental Health Subcommittee.
Wainberg et al. argue that “future DSM models could embed culture and … intersectionality not only as contextual variables that modify stressors, access, and stigma, but also as central, transdiagnostic processes shaping diagnosis, treatment, and recovery.”
They propose that viewing so-called socioeconomic, cultural, and environmental determinants of health (SCE-DoH) “through an intersectional lens places emphasis on the fact that structural advantages and disadvantages do not affect everyone equally due to differential exposure to risk and access to support.”
They argue, moreover, that “[a] richer integration [of] SCE-DoH as both context and process is essential to capturing the complexity of lived experience and ensuring diagnostic equity and accuracy.”
As is often the case with bad ideas, there is a kernel of truth here. Psychiatrists should consider the extent to which their patients’ psychiatric illnesses have a cultural context. And it is certainly the case that one’s environment, real or virtual (e.g., social media), can adversely impact one’s mental health.
Nevertheless, the thinking expressed by Wainberg et al. is dangerous. Proposing that intersectionality and its perceived “systems of oppression” be treated as “central, transdiagnostic processes shaping diagnosis” risks placing ideological constructs on equal diagnostic footing with the appearance, duration, and clinical significance of actual psychiatric symptoms.
More than that: By focusing on patients’ “intersectional” identities — i.e., their presumed victimization as a result of their race and gender and disability status, religion, et cetera — psychiatrists risk reducing individual care-seekers to representatives of crass political categories.
The second commentary in question, “Initial Strategy for the Future of DSM,” offers more of the same, contending, for example, that “entrenched responses to racial characteristics … have an impact on psychiatric assessment” and that the future DSM has a goal of “integrating … socioeconomic, cultural and environmental determinants of mental health.”
As lead author María A. Oquendo, MD, PhD, chair of the overall Future DSM Strategic Committee, notes, the Dahlgren-Whitehead model of health determinants “recommends consideration of socioeconomic, cultural, and environmental determinants in clinical formulations and treatment planning.” They add that the future DSM should “integrate these determinants and intersectionality into psychiatric assessment.”
That plan isn’t a good one for patients of any race. Yes, psychiatrists must take into account the cultural contexts of mental-health disorders, as previously acknowledged, but to wed “social determinants of health” ideology to “intersectionality,” as Oquendo et al. propose, is necessarily to go beyond scientifically grounded diagnostics and treatment into the realm of political theory.
Moreover, as Do No Harm has previously explained, it is not the role of medical professionals to become activists or reformers. Such activities naturally follow from “social determinants of health” ideology and are well beyond the purview of physicians. (Again, we grant that doctors must seek to understand the context in which a particular disease presents.)
As for nonpsychiatric medicine, so for psychiatric medicine: The mission creep that occurs when psychiatrists chase the Dahlgren-Whitehead rainbow comes at the detriment of medicine’s core focus. Diagnostic accuracy and proper treatment will follow when psychiatrists examine the patients in front of them as individuals, not as representatives of intersectionally victimized classes.
If the next version of the DSM encourages that framework instead of the one described in these commentaries, it will have done very well.

