A Medical Journal’s Unfalsifiable ‘Gender’ Contentions Are Not Science
Karl Popper is rolling over in his grave. The father of “falsifiability” — the notion that a properly scientific contention must be at least theoretically disprovable — would simply not believe a recent “comment” in Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Mental Health.
That article, Jamie D. Agapoff et al.’s “Gender-affirming psychiatry: a minority stress and phenomenological framework for child and adolescent mental health,” argues that delaying children’s access to so-called gender-affirming care “should not be regarded as a neutral approach.”
Rather, “[f]rom a phenomenological perspective, psychiatric care begins by taking patients’ lived experiences seriously, regardless of age.”
But what of critics’ recognition that most children who meet the criteria for gender dysphoria will eventually desist in those feelings — that their “lived experiences” are likely temporary and thus no basis for harmful and irreparable medical interventions?
Agapoff et al. attempt to cloud that reality: “What we have come to know as ‘desistance’ is best understood as the impact of social pressure rather than a true loss of gender identity.”
Moreover, “[d]esistance, like concealment, may be better understood as an adaptive response in some to adverse social conditions, rather than evidence against the stability of transgender identities.”
The reader will note the authors’ attempt to smuggle in a double standard. Children who plead that their “gender identity” and biological sex fail to align must be “tak[en] … seriously” at any age.
Yet children who profess to no longer feel that way are simply bowing to the pressures of a “transphobic” world.
The latter is the very definition of unfalsifiability. You say one thing, your psychiatrist argues that you’ve been manipulated, and there the matter stands. A patient’s belief about the origin of his own opinions may be subject to ideological nitpicking, but it is not measurable or disprovable by science.
Attempts to do so are, in a word, unfalsifiable.
Agapoff et al.’s defense of their claim is riddled with other errors in logic.
The authors write, for example, that “[m]ore recent longitudinal studies show that when gender-diverse youth are supported, rates of persistence are high.”
But that assertion ignores the role of parental and physician “support” in encouraging gender-dysphoric kids to persist. As Kenneth J. Zucker pointed out in “The myth of persistence,” “parents who support, implement, or encourage a gender social transition (and clinicians who recommend one) are implementing a psychosocial treatment that will increase the odds of long-term persistence.”
Encouraging a child to say something, in other words, increases the chances that he will do so.
Elsewhere in their “comment,” Agapoff et al. play many of the old hits, arguing, for instance, that “current recommendations from major professional organizations consistently support individualized, developmentally appropriate gender-affirming care delivered within comprehensive multidisciplinary assessment” (emphasis added).
What about the Cass Review? What about the American Society of Plastic Surgeons?
They refer to “[g]ender affirming psychiatry as an emerging evidence-based practice” but include compromised evidence — or none.
Yet the article’s greatest flaw remains the one that would get Sir Popper riled up were he around today. The claim that desistence from gender dysphoria is mostly impossible may be pleasing to ideologues of a certain stripe, but it isn’t science.

