Does the Pennsylvania Medical Society Speak For Doctors?
Is election season leaving you sick to your stomach? Pennsylvanians may be even more nauseated to learn what’s happening at one of our state’s most important medical institutions.
The Pennsylvania Medical Society held its annual meeting in Hershey over the weekend. Surprisingly, the organization that represents the Commonwealth’s doctors chose mediocrity over excellence and ideology over evidence when it comes to medical education. That should worry every Pennsylvanian, since all of us depend on excellent medical care.
As a psychiatrist, I’ve been a member of the society for 15 years, and I attended this year’s meeting as a delegate. I also work at a medical organization that advocates for the highest standards of physician training and patient care. As such, I submitted several resolutions for my fellow physicians to consider, in the hopes of reaffirming our state’s commitment to equal and excellent medical care.
My first resolution was simple: I urged the Pennsylvania Medical Society to support stronger standards in the national medical licensing exam. The exam is taken in three stages, known as “steps,” that aspiring physicians must pass to obtain a medical license. Yet in 2022, the first step dropped numeric scoring in favor of a pass/fail system.
The reason is disturbing: Political activists have long opposed numeric scoring on the grounds of “equity.” Specifically, they dislike that white and Asian students tend to get higher grades, on average, than black and Hispanic students. Ditching the grades helps cover that up. As national medical organizations have argued, the change helps “minimize racial demographic differences.”
But hiding reality is dangerous — for patients. Without grades, residency programs struggle to tell which medical students are the most likely to become the best physicians. Students themselves also have less reason to excel, because there’s little benefit to studying harder. That doesn’t bode well for patients, who need every physician to strive for excellence, not just “good enough.”
Unfortunately, the delegates to the Pennsylvania Medical Society meeting saw no problem encouraging mediocrity. They ultimately voted down my resolution 153 to 26.
I also offered a resolution opposing the politicization of continuing medical education. Many states — including our neighbors in Maryland and New Jersey — require many medical professionals to get training in things like “implicit bias” and “structural racism” as a condition of maintaining their license. Yet the science behind these trainings is shaky, at best, and telling patients their doctors can’t be trusted to treat them fairly risks real harm to the doctor-patient relationship.
The overriding message of this training is that doctors often mistreat patients with different skin colors. That’s an insult to physicians and a direct threat to patient trust in healthcare, which is low enough already. Besides, when doctors have to spend time learning about their own “bias” and “systems of oppression,” they aren’t spending time learning about the latest clinical skills and treatment strategies. Continuing medical education should promote better healthcare, not activist talking points. It should be based on scientific rigor, and as a medical society we should be proud to say that.
Sadly, my second resolution failed, as well. Only 66 of the delegates in attendance voted in favor, while 113 voted against it.
But do the delegates who voted against my resolutions really speak for Pennsylvania’s physicians? Many were medical students, not physicians, and overall there were less than 200 delegates actively participating — a fraction of the state’s 49,000 active doctors. Most physicians I know steer clear of the organization because they don’t see its value or oppose its politicization. But the Pennsylvania Medical Society still purports to be “the voice” of all the state’s doctors. In reality, it speaks for a small, self-selected slice of the profession — and its votes shouldn’t be mistaken for the views of Pennsylvania’s physicians.
In my experience, doctors want what patients deserve: a world-class medical system that trains excellent physicians and provides excellent care. It pains me that my own state medical society is fighting against this noble and necessary goal. But until more doctors get involved — and I hope they do — the Pennsylvania Medical Society will suffer from the same sickening politicization that defines the current election season.

